|
| Larviculture newsletter < Year 2005 < Issue 226 |
| |
back to top |
QUESTION:
I’m looking for optimal ozone concentration to sterilize sea water used
for shrimp postlarvae rearing, maturation and algae culture. Also a kit or
instrument to test the ozone machine is adding the required amount of O3 to
the system and if it disappears before it gets into the system.
Jaime Baquerizo baqueriziojaime@yahoo.com
*********************
COMMENTS 1:
Years ago, we used a small poly mix tank (20 Gal) and a mazzi injector to inject O3 into 50 L/Min flow. This went into a larger 1000 gallon tank (or was it 1500??), with a residual holding time of approximately 1 hour, min. We monitored ORP and kept the level up to 750 to 900 mV by controlling the O3 injection. The O3 was generated by a Clearwater system, with an O2 generator on the front end. Worked well, but watch out for the O3. This not only kills bugs, but people! Keep the system well ventilated (best, just keep it outdoors). O3 gets everywhere, and it's dangerous. We eventually stopped using the technique. If you're looking for algae, just go to Reed Mariculture (www.seafarm.com). At their prices, you can't afford to grow it.
COMMENTS 2:
Currently the system is under ozone action and I haven’t seen any probs in any of the area, larviculture, maturation or algae, but the system is set but no one knows the amount of ozone that is injected to the water (125 gpm), if it really is working effectively. The way we are using to measure if it is present in the water after the unit, is with a swimming pool chlorine test kit. One thing I’m sure is that it is not affecting the animals. I would like to know the right amount to be effective in treating seawater and find a method or instrument to measure if there is no residue before the seawater goes into LRTs.
Jaime Baquerizo baqueriziojaime@yahoo.com
We ozonate our complete reservoir to 750 mv. We then run the water through activated carbon. If you do not run it through activated carbon you will kill everything from post larval 1 down. Post larval 2 and up can handle straight ozonated water. We do not know why the change at metamorphosis. The chlorine test is simple and effective.
Larry Drazba ldrazba@ibw.com.ni
COMMENTS 4:
Have you tried to use sodium thiosulfate as an indicator for the residual presence of ozone? In seawater you may have to add some edta but is should work. I think LaMotte has a test kit but something tells me it is for freshwater and not seawater. We use the sodium thiosulfate in our lab as an indicator.
Ozonation of brackish or seawater results in the production of different by-product oxidants to freshwater. Ozone reacts with bromide and chloride ions in saltwater to produce relatively stable oxidants that are toxic to aquatic organisms.Use of ozone in saltwater systems is usually restricted to batch treatment of water separate to the main recirculating flow. Activated carbon filtration can be used to remove residual ozone and other oxidants from ozonated saltwater.
Howard W. Newman bshrimp@aol.com
COMMENTS 5:
Thanks for your reply on this "ozone case". Yes we pass through carbon filters when we repump ozone treated water into the system. I feel we've been using this system like "blind leading the blind", I don’t want to take more chances of risks. I know that O3 works and could be your friend if you know how to use it, I don’t want more "smelling testing", "odor verification" that the machine is injecting O3 to the system and that "has no residual" using the same senses methods.
Jaime Baquerizo baqueriziojaime@yahoo.com
COMMENTS 6:
In order for ozone to be effective, you have the get the ORP potential up to at least 750 mV. We let it go as high as 900 in situations where we knew there was a lot of bugs and organic material in the water. This takes a lot of ozone. The ORP probe was mounted in the outflow of the poly mix tank, and controlled the O3 injection. The ORP probe was a special one made by Phoenix probes just for this purpose. A standard ORP probe will die quickly in this environment.
As Larry said, you can run the outflow through an activated charcoal filter to kill the O3, but it chews up filters fast. And activated filters aren't cheap. If you can let the water breath for a bit, this also works. But you have to do it outdoors. We used the big holding tank to let the saltwater 'breath' and naturally dissipate the ozone. The ozonated water from the poly mix tank was injected in the bottom. Treated water was taken off the top of the tank. We kept it well stirred at the top by using submersible pumps in the tank.
We also used a standard ORP probe (along with pH and other probes) mounted in the outlet line to make sure the outflow level was below 200 mV. We found this to be a safe level for most critters. The chlorine test is also good. In our case, we had to use the ORP probes because ours was a continuous flow system, but we did spot checks with the chlorine test as well.I don't know much about raising shrimp, only read about it, and copy the Dallas and Julio, et. al. traffic whenever possible. But is it possible that the PL-1 were still very much dependent on algal feeds, and would simply starve to death if placed in the ozonated water? Maybe a combination of stress and lack of algae? I know that water with an ORP of 750 will kill any algae around, so is this a possible cause?
COMMENTS 7:
We've been using ozone in our commercial hatchery for more than 5 years with no problems during the whole cycle. Our system is based on a flow through system and has protected us from some problems in the area as red tides, we were the only hatchery producing PLs during this time, the only difference the ozone. Anyway, my concern is that I know we are injecting O3 to the seawate , before the reservoir, how much, what concentration 500, 600, 750, 100 mV right after the ozonifier only God knows. Sometimes agar plates for bacteria before and after O3 show difference, sometines don’t. That’s why I’m trying to find an instrument to calibrate the right concentration for O3 injection and no residual after carbon filters, aeration in the reservoir. I know that O3 is a great tool for production but can be very dangerous also, as spermatophores problems in maturation as an example.
Jaime Baquerizo baqueriziojaime@yahoo.com
COMMENTS 8:
Jaime, I see your problem. We eliminated that problem by having a reservoir where we recirculate the water through filters and ozone and only after we have reached a desired endpoint (750 vm) do we pass the water over the activated carbon to the animals. We set it up that way for exactly that reason.
Larry Drazba ldrazba@ibw.com.ni
COMMENTS 9:
I use a series of protein skimmers to remove ozone fter ozonating the water online in a recirculating system which rears Zoea thro' Mysis and subsequently Post larvae too. The half life of Ozone (L50) is substantially reduced with higher levels of dissolved and suspended organic matter in the water. The amount of ozone required and thereafter the amount of time required to remove it directly depends on how much organic matter (dissolved and suspended) you have in the rearing water at the given time.
Anil Ghanekar anilghanekar@yahoo.com
COMMENTS 10:
The previous comment about bromine is a serious issue with ozone and salt water. If you are trying for real sterilization (not just feed good approaches), you will form hypobromous acid, which is very toxic and much more stable that ozone itself. Activated carbon will work, but you will get bacteria growing in the carbon and whether these are detrimental or probiotic bacteria or just irrelevant species is just a gamble. If you have enough organic material for froth flotation units (the correct name for "protein skimmers" that really skim surface active components and hydrophobic solids, may or may not be protein) to work after hard ozonation, you probably have some water quality issues that should be addressed before the use of ozone. Ozone in water can also be removed with UV light and this process creates an even stronger oxidizing action than ozone or UV alone. This process is in the category of Advanced Oxidation Processes (AOP) that are used industrially to oxidize very refractory organic chemical (often very toxic and nasty stuff).
Dallas E. Weaver, Ph.D.
Scientific Hatcheries
5542 Huntington Beach, CA 92649
714-890-0138
Fax 714-890-3778
www.ScientificHatcheries.com
deweaver@surfcity.net
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| |
back to top |
| back to top |
© Copyright 2000 - Laboratory of Aquaculture & Artemia Reference Center - Ghent University, Belgium